R E L A T E D   C O N T E N T

Free email newsletters




ADVERTISEMENT

Microsoft patent claim a 'spoiling tactic'

Alleged Linux infringements fall with a FUD on European conference on patent law

Clive Akass, Personal Computer World 17 May 2007
ADVERTISEMENT

Microsoft's claim that Linux infringes its patents was dismissed today as a tactic to spoil a European conference on rationalising the law on the subject.

The company claims the open-source kernel violates 42 patents and Linux graphical user interfaces such as Gnome and KDE fall foul of another 65. It also claimed that Openoffice infringes 45, and other open-source projects violate another 83.

Linux guru Linus Torvalds has already challenged Microsoft to "put up or shut up" on the issue.

And today Graham Taylor, chief executive of OpenForum Europe, said Microsoft's comments seemed designed to cause FUD (fear, uncertainty and doubt) and derail the European Patent Conference in its attempts to find a " patent system fit for the 21st century".

He said in a statement: "The claims made by Microsoft do not refer to the way patents are infringed, which patents are infringed or who is committing the infringement."

Microsoft should give "specific and detailed instances" or be prepared for people to ignore them, as they ignored similar claims by Unix house SCO.

But people would not ignore the fact that Microsoft made its claims as representatives of industry, academia, and European policy-making bodies were seeking to formulate a patent policy that benefited both innovators and society.

The statement continued: "There was a concerted opinion [at the conference] that patents need to be carefully balanced with societal interests, particularly in the standard setting context where patents may impede interoperability.

"Microsoft's actions are in direct contravention to this need. They seem intended to disrupt such effects, cloud the issues, and keep in place the status quo."

Taylor claimed Microsoft's action posed questions about whether its new OpenXML documents formats, which have been submitted to ISO for approval as an open standard, could qualify as such in the eyes of "those who seek a truly open system, avoiding the cost of lock-in to proprietary systems".


All

Like this story? Spread the news by clicking below:

Post this to Delicious del.icio.us    Post this to Digg Digg this    Post this to reddit reddit!

Permalink for this story
R E A D E R   C O M M E N T S

M A R K E T P L A C E
Sponsored links
F E A T U R E D   J O B S
London, United Kingdom | BP
 IT Leader -£ Competitive - London About BP Our business is the exploration, production, refining, trading and distribution of energy. This is what we do, and we do it on a truly global scale. With ... more >
United Kingdom | ESRC
Web/Project Manager - £33,118 to £35,694 + Benefits Cutting-edge research is our business. You'll give us the cutting-edge web technologies to match. The Economic and Social Research Council is the UK's leading research agency for ... more >
Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, United Kingdom | Grass Roots
SQL Database Administrator - Aylesbury - £DOEGrass Roots are one of the Sunday Times Top 100 companies to work for (2007 and 2008). Established in 1980, we're part of the Grass Roots Group, which is ... more >
Central London, United Kingdom | Royal Academy of Music
Head of Technology - London - Competitive salary & benefits The Head of Technology will lead and direct the Academy's Technology department, working with Senior Management to define and implement the IT strategy. The postholder ... more >
More job opportunities